The oldest religious denomination in Bimini, it was originally comprised of two Churches - St. Stephen's in Alice Town (1874) and St. Mary's in Bailey Town (1878). In 1921 they were combined and dedicated as Our Lady's and St. Stephen's on the present site in Bailey Town. Their annual picnic is a homecoming of sorts and features games, food, music, a kiddies' corner and more. Venue is Bailey Town in North Bimini.